I alway's go with the best price as we are there for a little over two weeks. You will get many different answers from different people. But as long as the price is right and the car is in decent shape we are happy. This will be my 6th trip and I have used, Ace, Caribbean twice, Econo, and Royal. I have never really had a problem with any of them. Right now I am doing some pricing and will decide within the next week who I will reserve with. I don't mind a car with a few scratches on it, especially in Aruba we go snorkeling and exploring and I don't have to worry about damaging a new car.

Good luck in your search and have a great vacation!