Like everything else, it depends on what you are looking for- We like the Phoenix because it is a relatively small resort, and no matter where your room is you have ocean view(except in villas) and you are never far from the beach. La Cabana is too big for us- could be a long walk to beach, and can't gaurantee view. Beach is also much busier. I'm sure there are a lot more things to do at Cabana (food options,activities, etc), but we're not looking for activities, just relaxation.