I've been to Marina Pirata. It was good, but I don't know if it's worth the cab fare. For us it was far and cost about 25.00. I liked Pinchos just as much and it was a lot closer to our hotel. I guess it depends on where you are staying.
We rent an SUV 4 x 4 for only one day of our trip. That is the night that we go to Marina Pirata because of the fact that the taxi fare is so expensive.
Aruba Bound! ~ Blogging to Aruba ~ Hoosier Kitties ~ Pictures of Aruba