We loved Rib night at Matthews two weeks ago, but we had mixed results on Italian Night. Tortuga Grille at ABC had a better deal with all-you-can-eat Pasta Night. I tried both red and white clam sauce and found them both tasty. Others enjoyed the ala vodka sauce.
Tortuga Grille was a great, quiet pavillion overlooking the beach and the water. They have many specials and we all enjoyed the food. It hasn't gotten the ink that Matthews has and doesn't offer Kareoke Night or other advertised specials, but was a solid choice for good food at reasonable prices.