Just got back- for what its worth, here were my favorites:
El Gauchos- The gaucho steak is awesome, service excellent. Got some Gaucho steak sauce to go 5 out of 5 forks
Madam Jeanettes- wonderful atmosphere, will go back. Had the fish- it was a little dry, but my wifes pork was excellent-all in all a great meal. 4 out of 5 forks
Iguana Joes- servicable food nothing fancy- burgers and burritos- great drinks though. 3 out of 5 forks
Driftwood- me and the guys want deep sea fishing earlier in the day and caught a couple of Mahi Mahi- they cooked them for us and 12 of us ate like kings. cooked 4 ways, and served with different sauces, it was heaven on a plate. Banana cake for dessert rocks too. 5 out of 5 forks.
Screaming Eagle- short walk from where we were staying (La Cabana) The food is wonderful, and we sat outdoors, so the place is beautiful. Got the Carte Blanche (chefs choice- I was feeling adventurous) was very pleased. 3 courses for 59.00 Beef Carpaccio, braised duck, and a sampling of all 6 desserts on the menu. 5 out of 5 forks (and then some) my favorite of all.
Islander Grill at La Cabana- good breakfast good lunch- convenient for us (right by the pool) 3 out of 5 forks
I will hit all of these places when I go back for sure.