We are big foodies and are spoiled by living in Boston for 35 years, so by now we have become experts at eating ;-)
Our top 5 are....
Carte Blanche - The best overall dining experience ever
Marina Pirata - Great location/atmosphere and fantastic seafood
Zeerovers - I just love the fact that my meal was swiming 20 min ago
Barefoot - We have never had a bad dish here
Most of the Food Trucks and in house restaurants throughout the island - The mystery of it all, just adds to the experience
Note: We have not tried Scott's yet and are looking forward to it in April. Texas de Brazil is outstanding, but they are a national chain and are not exclusive to Aruba.