We are on the island for a week. I have reservations at a few places that came recommended (Barefoot, Pinchos, Fishbones, Matthews). I am leaving a few open days as I want to go to Wacky Wahoos and Zeerovers and they don't have online reservations.
My question, if I don't have reservations for every night are there a lot of restaurants that we can get into without them that are good?
Also, I'm still trying to figure out where to go for our first night there. We get in around 4pm. Need to pick up our car, cell phone and a few groceries and then plan on heading to the hotel to get settled and change for dinner so I figure maybe 6:30 reservations so we can see the sunset. Any recommendations to make it a great first night on the island?