Just posted all of our restaurant reviews at:
In a nutshell, we really didn't have any bad meals on the island. Had a few issues at Milano regarding food and service but they are going through some "new restaurant growing pains" and they made amends to us. So we may give them another try on the next trip.
Favorites: Screaming Eagle, Passions, and Amadeus
But all of the others were good, too! And there were so many places we wanted to eat at but just didn't have enough time....