well we decided on Del Rey. About a mile from the beach as well but it can hold 6 in 2 bedrooms. Also getting slight discount on a car. I hope we made the right call. @ $151 USD all inclusive (taxes / etc) I don't think we could do better
Don't forget there are other places like Buffam's Tropical Haven. They only have 4 rooms and are about a 2 minute drive to the beach, Ling's, and so forth. Cozy place with breakfast, private pool, and lots of tranquilo vibe.