No debate this year...LOL. We are renting a 4wd truck from Yes Rental. They are advertising some really good specials - only $400 for the entire week so there was really nothing to debate. The one year we rented a car, Jon said he thinks we didn't use it enough and prefers the option to go off road if he feels like it. I don't think we need something for the whole week, but with the deals right now it just made sense.